Running Warehouse banner

Trail Running Course

Salomon Skin Pro 3 Running Pack – Trail Running Gear Review

Hiking in the Maroon Bells last year I encountered a couple of runners coming off a pass and noticed one of them wearing an incredibly cool looking Salomon pack. I just caught a glimpse and when I arrived home looked around online to find out what it was. My best guess at the time was that it was the then newly released Salomon XT Advanced Skin S-lab pack. I couldn’t really justify another pack since I’d recently purchased the Nathan Endurance and the hefty $180 price tag of the XT made the decision easier, but couldn’t resist when given the opportunity to test one of its smaller less flamboyant cousins; the Salomon Skin Pro 3.

Salomon Skin Pro 3 (Photo: Courtesy Running Warehouse / runningwarehouse.com)

Out of box appeal of most Salomon products is just plain sexy and the Skin Pro 3 is no exception. This 10.7oz (weighed out of box) with 50oz hydration system looks great. And it delivers. It’s a small pack with a number of smart features built in. It comes in two colors; red and green. If you are from New Mexico and you understand the significance of red and green, you’ll know I went with the green cuz I’m a green chile guy! Small features like the built in whistle, removable insulation sleeve for the bladder, reflective hits and 4D pole system are what makes Salomon so popular; they think of ways to give the most bang without adding a ton of weight., e.g. the 4D pole system is a six inch strap with a squeeze clasp and loop at one end and can be used to attach a helmet, a pole or just about any other light weight item you might need to secure.

The pack has a large rear main pocket along the backside that will hold food, a small jacket and a couple odds and ends. There are two elastic pockets for bottles or food along each side of the main rear pocket. On the left front chest strap there is a small zippered pocket large enough to hold one gel or a couple very small items and on the right front chest strap there is an elastic pocket with room to store 1-2 gels.

What I like

Unlike my Nathan Endurance pack, adjusting this pack so it fits right takes very little time. The Nathan fits well, but takes more work to get it perfect. There are two velcro pads build into the top of each shoulder that take seconds to adjust. The front sternum straps are made of a thin elastic fabric with two small hook closures that are easy to connect to the opposite side of the pack. I liked them specifically because they didn’t rub on my heart rate monitor the way most chest straps do. Not a huge deal but Salomon thought through a better way to design the chest strap.

The hydration bladder is 50oz and comes with the same style fold and slide closure that the Nathan packs have. I found the Salomon version easier to use and additionally there is a quick-disconnect so it’s easy to remove the bladder for cleaning without having to unthread the hose from the pack.

I had no unwanted motion with this pack. It fits higher up on the torso than any of my other packs and fits snuggly around the arms. Its close to body profile keeps weight from getting too far from the line of gravity so rotation and bounce is almost completely eliminated. Whereas with my Nathan pack I notice the faster I go the more bounce I get, with the Skin Pro, it’s snug at all speeds.

One of the other really nifty features is the bladder hose. It comes out the bottom of the back and is guided up towards the front of the chest strap by three small guide loops. This puts the hose and mouthpiece right at mouth level when needed rather than over the shoulder. It’s a much smoother design than any other hydration pack I’ve worn. However, it’s not without its issues.

What I don’t like

Out of the box the hose stays very snug in the loop enclosures and so the distance from mouth to mouthpiece is pretty close. However, once broken in, the mouthpiece slides down to the last loop and any excess tubing gets fed out the last loop so there’s more hose at the bottom. When you need a drink, it takes both hands to pull the hose back up high enough to reach the mouthpiece. This is actually more of a pain than I anticipated. It takes two hands to coordinate because of the way the hose is fed through the loops. It’s definitely something I’d like to see Salomon address with the next version.

Construction! Although Salomon products look great, I’ve been disappointed with the quality of their materials and sewing. I’ve had extremely bad luck with one version of their running tights that I will not buy again because the sewing was so poor. I went through two pairs of running tights in two months and returned them to REI, only to find that the three that they had in stock were already faulty in the same spot I’d had problems with (stitching).

So I am very cautious how I look at Salomon products because they are so expensive and don’t always hold together well. This pack was no exception. On the first run the stitching around the top edge of the elastic pouch on the front chest strap tore out. Other than that, however, two months and a ton of miles later, this pack has held up to all the demands I’ve placed on it.

Design flaws include creating a pack that will carry enough water for 3-5 hours but not putting any substantial food storage system within reach. The two pockets in the rear take an enormous amount of shoulder flexibility and dexterity to get access too. I’ve ended up stopping and taking the pack off to get food out because it’s just easier. The front pockets will only hold three gels at most and if you use them for gels, anything else you might want to have at your fingertips is relegated to the rear compartment. For this reason, I’d probably never race with this pack unless I carried food elsewhere.

One of the folks I run with told me that Salomon makes compatible accessories for their packs however the product information card says this pack is not compatible. The Salomon website isn’t super clear but it might still work to buy an accessory pouch. It’s a pack that would be a great deal more powerful if calories could be stored without having to turn into a pretzel to reach them.

My final complaint is a fit concern. When I have the pack loaded for a long run and put it on, there is a pressure point along my clavicle where the chest straps encounter the velcro sleeve. Over the course of a couple long weekend runs, these actually bruised and made it very uncomfortable to wear the pack for a few days. I’ve played around with fit and can’t seem to get it to “ride” differently but that may be an issue with my clavicles and not the pack.

What’s the BOTTOM LINE?

For mid-short training days (3-5 hours) this 10.7oz pack with 50oz bladder will carry everything you should need. Apart from the pressure point along my clavicle this pack fits like a glove and I don’t even notice it’s on. Salomon’s put in some nice design features that let you know they’ve been listening to feedback and runners for what they want.

Honestly, there’s not a lot wrong with this pack. Yes, I just wrote six paragraphs describing glaring flaws as I see them, but none of those flaws (outside maybe the food accessibility) is large enough to stray from this pack. I’ll find ways to get around the food issue because I like the fit and design of the pack more.

If you are “bigger” built person, I’d recommend trying this out in the store first. I’m 5’10” 145lbs and the pack fit me great out of box but for larger frames, it may not work.

Have you worn the Salomon Skin Pro 3 pack? What are your thoughts on it?

What pack system are you currently using and why do you like it?

– Jason Taylor


You can purchase the Salomon Skin Pro 3 running pack at Running Warehouse (Shoes, Packs, Clothes, Lights, and more…plus 2-day free shipping!).

Photo: Courtesy Running Warehouse / runningwarehouse.com



About the author

Jason Taylor Jason Taylor reawakened his love of running in 2008 and continues to pursue longer ultra adventures. Jason’s life goal is to inspire, influence and transform others through his love for running and his passion for life. For more information on Jason, check out the About page.

8 Responses to “Salomon Skin Pro 3 Running Pack – Trail Running Gear Review”

  1. on 14 Jun 2012 at 2:32 pm Chris

    I’m enjoying these reviews you’re doing for EB Jason. In fact, my Amphipod waist pack should be arriving today. After running Caldera with my Nathan pack, I knew I wanted to go back to handhelds with a small waist pack. Your review of that one made the search a lot easier.

  2. on 15 Jun 2012 at 12:44 am Stefan

    Funny that you would mention the fit issue with clavicle. I experience the same with my Skin Pro 10+3. But so far it hasn’t really bothered me yet.

    My other major complaint is the pole attachement system. Here in the mountains we really like using them but the system on the pack is sort of pointless:

    http://bavarianrunner.blogspot.com/2012/06/salomon-xa-pro-skin-103-finally-pack.html

  3. on 15 Jun 2012 at 8:10 am TK42ONE

    I have the Advanced Skin 5 pack and encountered pretty much the same issues. Nearly impossible to reach the pockets on the sides by your kidneys and the stitching is quite poor. But aside from that, I do like it better than my Nathan HPL 020.

  4. on 16 Jun 2012 at 5:01 pm Jason

    Chris, thanks, and enjoy the amphipod. I am still using mine almost daily. It’s such a simple piece of equipment but one that I’m totally in love with.

    Stefan and TK42ONE, I think that Salomon needs to take a look a their manufacturing process and make sure they are producing a better made, more durable product. Thanks for the comments. Stefan – I haven’t tried the pole attachment but based on my own estimation on what I’d use the pack for, at this point, I think it was a bit over kill on this one. Not like it added any real weight but it’s just extra fluff that doesn’t necessarily do much.

  5. on 25 Jun 2012 at 7:58 am Thomas

    Thanks Jason for this good review. I am wondering how time consuming or difficult it is to open/close the two red hook clambs which hold the front straps.

    It looks like – especially when not standing in front of a mirror – that it is rather difficult to lock/unlock them.

    Or is the whole idea to keep them locked all the time and to get this pack onto the shoulders by squeezing through?

  6. on 25 Jun 2012 at 9:27 am Jason

    Thomas, great question. Actually the hook attachment is super easy to clip and unclip. One of the nicer features of the pack. Very easy to adjust on the run as well. I do find that it takes two hands to unclip if I want to do it quickly but it’s really simple. Hope that helps. Are you thinking of purchasing one?

  7. on 01 Jul 2012 at 8:09 pm Kent Keeler

    Great review. I just posted a review of the same pack (though mine is red!) Once i got a feel for where the two rear elastic pockets were I have been able to retrieve gels, etc from them without too much struggle while it is on. I also noticed the issue with the hose but found if i tightened up the pole strap i could tuck the bite valve under and it kept it in place a little better.

    Have a look at my thoughts if you’re interested – http://wp.me/p2mxMe-9d

    Also if you want a pack that has more room for “stuff” i have also reviewed the XT Wings 10+3 pack on my site.

    Thanks,
    kent

  8. on 03 Jul 2012 at 2:24 pm Jason

    Kent,
    Thanks, great ideas. I will definitely try out the pole strap. I find that I just don’t have the shoulder flexibility to get at the gel pockets without a lot of work. I still find that the biggest issue for me is the spots on my clavicle where it rubs. Yikes! I’ve started using thick bandaids on the spots where it rubs!!